Boss promotes employee to ‘leadership role’ but doesn't include a raise or added benefits, just more responsibilities: ‘Calling it a “promotion” felt dishonest’

Author image for Lana DeGaetano
Lana DeGaetano • "Show me to me please."
Mar 9, 2025 4:00 PM EDT

Any employee preparing for a bump-up on the corporate hierarchy knows that a promotion isn't a promotion unless you have the supplemental compensation to prove it. Sure, a new title to slap on the ol' resume and more responsibilities to fill your time during the workday is nice, but you don't want to be doing any extra work if you're not seeing an appropriate payout along with that. Your labor is not free… Any boss that tries to convince you otherwise is just trying to save that money for their own pockets and actively engaging in toxic workplace practices.

In this next story, an employee is left humiliated after their boss "promotes" them to a new title with more responsibilities but fails to give them a compensation raise or new benefits. Hey, that new job title is going to come in handy when they're back on the job hunt for a boss who won't take their time and effort for granted. Scroll to read.

Advertisement

  • If you haven't gone through something like this, consider yourself lucky. This type of inconsiderate treatment from a higher-up who's supposed to look out for you really feeds the fire of distrust many employees have for executive-level employees. This story us a testament to the fact that sometimes, no matter how hard you work, you will not be rewarded if you're under the supervision of a tyrant-like boss who couldn't care less about you trying to make a career for yourself.

  • "The room got awkward, and my boss just smirked and said, 'You should be grateful for the opportunity.""
    via Getty Images For Unsplash+

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • "AIO this, or did my boss just completely humiliate me with my ‘promotion’?"

    I thought I was finally getting recognized at work, but now I just feel like an absolute idiot. A few weeks ago, my boss pulled me into a meeting and hyped me up, saying I was doing amazing
    via politicooooo
  • work and they wanted to "reward" me. They offered me a new title and a "leadership role," which sounded exciting until I realized:
    via politicooooo
  • 1. No raise. Not even a cent. 2. No added benefits. 3. A fancy new title but I'm still doing the exact same job with more responsibilities.
    via politicooooo
  • The worst part? They announced it in a company-wide email like it was some huge promotion. People started congratulating
    via politicooooo
  • me, and I had to awkwardly smile and thank them while knowing I literally got nothing out of it except a meaningless title and more responsibilities.
    via politicooooo
  • Cheezburger Image 10476964608
    via Getty Images For Unsplash+

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • I asked my boss about a salary adjustment, and they smiled and said, "This is a stepping stone for you! If you work hard, there could be financial incentives NEXT YEAR*
    via politicooooo
  • That's when I kind of "snapped". I told him that I found it insulting to be given more work without fair pay and that calling it a
    via politicooooo
  • "promotion" felt dishonest. The room got awkward, and my boss just smirked and said, "You should be grateful for the opportunity."
    via politicooooo
  • Now I'm wondering, did I overreact? Should I have just played along and kept my mouth shut? Or was I right to call him out?
    via politicooooo
  • Actual-Discussion-89 lol I've been here. Your boss has done exactly what you suspect they have done. In my situation, when I pushed back & demanded to give the extra responsibilities back, they insisted that I take a pay cut, despite the fact that I didn't get a pay rise to take them on NOR.
    via Actual-Discussion-89
  • One-Put-3709 I'd leave. Or start shopping for another job.
    via One-Put-3709
  • bf-es They like to make people managers so suddenly they don't have to pay you OT
    via bf-es
  • BenneB23 Grateful for what opportunity, the opportunity to work more, with more responsibilities for the same pay? Good on you for standing your ground. Time to leave. There are more opportunities elsewhere. Tell them exactly why you're leaving.
    via BenneB23
  • Cutterbuck We have all been there, (those of us over 40 at least). Email back explaining you are excite about the prospect an ask what metrics you will be expected to hit to achieve the pay rise.
    via Cutterbuck
  • You now have your answer in writing. Either you decide to push for those targets or you decide you to take the new title and look for a new job that pays a salary that befits the title. a vague spoken promise of a new role, well that never delivers.
    via Cutterbuck
  • Muroid Time to take the fancy new title and use it to shop around for a job that will actually pay you for holding it.
    via Muroid
  • Alexis2337 Not overreacting. You did what most of us would want to do but are afraid to do. You spoke your mind lol. Im the exact same way.
    via Alexis2337
  • Its simple, if your not feeling valued, respected and just another of the companys tool/robot that will comply to anything. Then you have every right to put the foot down and say "No, this stops here." If you and Boss cant find any middle ground on your promotion then you know what you should do... cheers.
    via Alexis2337
  • Agency-Aggressive They expect you to just nod and go with it because that is the way everyone is now, up to you if you actually want to grow a set
    via Agency-Aggressive

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

boss aita antiwork workplace-stories toxic-workplace AITAH bosses work reddit story horrible-management workplace Horrible Bosses reddit thread bad bosses entitled people toxic-work-environment
Scroll Down For The Next Article